Every debate, open and closed

Pick a scene, study the frame, and put your voice on the record.

Showing 10 open debates

CASE #04 · Pulp Fiction

Was Vincent right to take Mia dancing?

A favor for the boss, or a line he shouldn't have crossed.

For the dance12
Against the dance9
Open now 32 claims Enter →
CASE #02 · Good Will Hunting

Was Will right to walk away from it all?

Choosing the girl over every door that was finally opening.

He was right7
He was wrong5
19 claims Enter →
CASE #05 · Taxi Driver

Is Travis a vigilante, or a warning sign?

The city failed him first — does that settle what he does next.

Vigilante11
Warning sign8
Open now 27 claims Enter →
#06
CASE #06 · The Warriors

Could Cyrus's truce ever have held?

One citywide peace, and one bullet to break it.

It could have held4
Doomed either way3
Open now 11 claims Enter →
CASE #08 · Toy Story

Did Woody's jealousy excuse what he did to Buzz?

Losing top shelf, and how far that fear was allowed to go.

Jealousy is human6
No excuse5
15 claims Enter →
CASE #09 · Men in Black

Should J have erased his old life?

The badge came with a price nobody explained up front.

Worth the cost3
Too high a price2
8 claims Enter →
CASE #21 · One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest

Was McMurphy's rebellion worth what it cost?

He gave the ward a spark — and paid for it in full.

Worth what it cost15
Not worth it13
41 claims Enter →
CASE #11 · Pirates of Silicon Valley

Did the ends justify Jobs' means?

Building the future while burning the people who built it with him.

The ends justified it5
Nothing justified it4
13 claims Enter →
#13
CASE #13 · Boogie Nights

Did the family fail Dirk, or did he fail them?

A borrowed name, a real family, and a fall neither side saw coming.

The family failed him3
He failed them2
Open now 9 claims Enter →
CASE #12 · Space Jam

Was benching Michael Jordan the right call?

A game on the line, and a decision the whole team has to live with.

The right call2
The wrong call2
6 claims Enter →